Innovatie Maturity Scan

The Innovation Maturity Scan consists of 12 parts with 5 statements each. For each statement, indicate to what extent it applies to your organization. A score of 1 is 'not applicable at all', a 2 is 'often not applicable', a 3 is 'sometimes yes/sometimes not applicable', a 4 is 'often applicable' and finally a score of 5 for 'fully applicable'.

Leadership - Goals

1. The organization has a clear mission statement in which the importance of innovation in order to connect to social transitions is identified and endorsed.
info_outline

The mission expresses the organisation's raison d'être. What do we stand for? This is a more static fact, often linked to the reason for incorporation. In relation to innovation, the long-term impact is therefore examined. Including innovation as a driving force to achieve the mission can be implicit ('we continuously improve our services') or explicit ('we see innovation as a means to accomplish the mission').

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
2. The organization has a clear vision of where the organization wants to move and what (the role of) innovation is in this.
info_outline

A vision related to innovation is an expression of the direction in which an organization wants to move through innovation and where it wants to be in 3 to 5 years and with a view on which activities will be undertaken.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
3. We have a strategy that includes innovation objectives in line with our mission, vision and activities.
info_outline

Innovation objectives can be included in the i-strategy, annual plans and/or relevant policy documents. Sometimes these are dictated very directly by a political assignment.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
4. With our commitment to innovation, we focus on long-term goals rather than short-term solutions.
info_outline

There is an overall sense and mood that today's efforts will drive the organization forward in the longer term. The focus is on making the innovation organization more mature (so that structural innovations land faster and with more effect in the organization) and not on ad hoc solutions.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
5. We have innovation goals in which the result to be achieved is clearly defined.
info_outline

The result to be achieved is formally and structurally recorded because it is included in, for example, the budget, annual plans or multi-year project plans, and partly because of this, it can count on the commitment of the highest management.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree

Leadership - Core values

6. Our leaders are consistent in propagating and standing for the (public) values ​​established by our organization.
info_outline

The organization supposedly has a clear 'DNA'. Where applicable, this is always included in development processes. This attitude is actively propagated, included in the innovation policy and the organization is therefore valued.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
7. We always discuss decisions and actions that deviate from the established values ​​in our services and activities.
info_outline

Deviations from the established values ​​do not take place ad hoc, but only deliberately and consciously.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
8. Value dilemmas around topics such as privacy, ethics, sustainability and inclusion are explicitly included in our development activities
info_outline

Taking such factors into account can on the one hand lead to extra effort or limitations in the implementation, but it is also often a unique factor that especially governments and not-for-profit institutions have to deal with.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
9. The government-wide frameworks and guidelines are known and followed when developing digital solutions.
info_outline

This means that the organization works 'by default' and 'by design' according to the government-wide principles, such as the BIO for security, NORA and use of standards for architecture, open source solutions, open data, implementation of privacy impact assessment for start of service, etc.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
10. We think and speak with respect about differences that may arise in policy and implementation at other organizational units.
info_outline

An expression of this is that, for example, there is active cooperation from the 'business' (policy) at an early stage of development with 'development' (development) and 'operations' (management) of the service, product or solution to be developed. A so-called BusDevOps approach. Central to this is that 'what is desirable' from a policy perspective is considered just as important as 'what is possible (or is already possible)' from a practical point of view.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree

Leadership - Stimulate

11. Top management has a proactive attitude toward innovation in general.
info_outline

Top management visibly stimulates the behavior of managers and employees. They feel challenged by the top to come up with ideas and proposals for new developments.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
12. Environmental analyses (such as technological developments, wishes of stakeholders and users) are a structural part of our way of working.
info_outline

It is not only important to know what your user group wants, but it can also relate to things like market developments, for example displacement effects: market parties taking over or picking up undesirable government tasks on their own initiative. Or think of a technology that offers your organization opportunities or threatens to make it redundant (is that perhaps a good development, where would it go wrong for the government in its core tasks, etc.)

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
13. The organization encourages employees to explore new opportunities.
info_outline

This is made concrete, for example, by challenging employees, submitting ideas or asking for so-called challenges among start-ups or during innovation events.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
14. We regularly organize or participate in innovative networks and/or events, such as lectures, workshops or conferences.
info_outline

Internal and external networks are very important in the exploration phase within innovation projects and events can also contribute to a good working atmosphere and knowledge transfer.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
15. Creativity is encouraged by applying new forms of work, such as design thinking, open innovation and/or encouraging new ways of looking at solutions.
info_outline

Management encourages everyone in the organization to start working (together) in a way that is appropriate to challenge. Current processes are not treated as sacred cows, but out-of-the-box thinking is desirable. Deployment of principles from the LEAN methodology also fits in here.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree

Culture - Setting

16. Innovation teams are assembled across the organizational structure based on the competencies and skills needed.
info_outline

So not by default are they based on departments or existing team composition. The organization consciously supports the use of cross- and multi-functional teams specifically set up for different types of projects and ways of working.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
17. Organization-wide, there is sufficient awareness of the added values that innovation can bring.
info_outline

Not every improvement delivers monetizable added value. It can therefore be both quantitative and qualitative. Sometimes an innovation also delivers benefits elsewhere in the organization or beyond. Broadly implemented and supported innovation management provides an organization in which innovation projects have a greater chance of success, acceptance and effectiveness.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
18. The organization shows guts and does not shy away from projects with high-risk but important potential added value.
info_outline

Sometimes it is necessary to carry out a project with a high risk of failure. With innovation, showing vision and guts and thus taking well-considered risks is the order of the day in order to stimulate new developments.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
19. The organizational culture provides room for experimentation where it can.
info_outline

Innovative organizations offer space for ideas, variation and experimentation because in such situations you learn better, give room for development and own initiative where possible. Stopping a project is not seen as failure, but as a moment of reflection and learning.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
20. The organization has a customer- and/or task-oriented orientation at all levels.
info_outline

The 'client' can be a customer, the citizen, a social task, company, institution, etc. It is about an 'outside in' approach. Insights from outside the organization are used to optimally serve 'the customer'. The organization thinks proactively with clients and end users and tailors its services and activities to them (a demand-oriented orientation) whereby innovation is actively used. Terms such as 'market-oriented work', 'the customer journey' and 'customer intimacy' are then used in the organization when talking about innovation.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree

Culture - Cooperation

21. Effective communication with all stakeholders is ensured around innovation projects and transition processes.
info_outline

Effective communication means that the recipient is not overwhelmed by the innovation, but above all understands (without too many technical and/or substantive terms) what the delivery means for the organization and its stakeholders.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
22. The organization makes an active commitment to the interaction between Government, Education and Enterprises.
info_outline

The organisation can actively participate in programs such as Startup In Residence, and other partnerships with companies and educational institutions.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
23. We have good opportunities for accessible, user-friendly and adequate information and knowledge sharing.
info_outline

The facilities are of such a nature that they are actually used and effective.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
24. When developing an innovation, we take into account the effects and impact elsewhere in the organisation.
info_outline

Almost all execution nowadays takes place within chains that need to (re)use each other's data. Thinking and setting up ecosystems and collaborative platforms is of great importance here. In addition, a government innovation can be very positive, but can also lead to concerns or side effects (whether desired or not). Think for example of privacy aspects. Or it may involve extra costs for citizens, companies or within the government. Taking this into account at the start is requested here.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
25. Our values and principles in relation to our innovation activities are clearly communicated to all stakeholders.
info_outline

Communicating what you stand for and what principles and conditions you use as an organization is an important aspect of embedding innovation in all work processes. This applies both to mutual cooperation within your own organization and with other departments or external parties.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree

Social - Workplace

26. Room for creativity and personal initiatives of an entrepreneurial nature are encouraged through the use of the workplace and (digital) facilities.
info_outline

There is generally an open culture where there is room for entrepreneurship, research and serendipity within the organization. The workplace supports this by responding to the needs of managers and employees.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
27. The workplace and facilities are up to date and invite people to work (together) in innovative ways.
info_outline

This can be in the office, options for working on location and/or at home (including digital support). This includes modern, digital presentation techniques and brainstorm tools.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
28. We have a strategic workplace plan that outlines objectives for innovative (collaborative) working.
info_outline

The organization has a vision of the role and added value of an innovation-tailored workplace plus facilities and also designs the organization and (digital) spaces accordingly.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
29. We have good and, where necessary, specially equipped workplaces and facilities to support innovation.
info_outline

This also involves (digital) facilities and goes far beyond compliance with occupational health policies. Does the workplace actively support innovation?

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
30. Facility preconditions to achieve proper implementation of an innovation project or organization are in place.
info_outline

The organization facilitates teams and employees with the necessary tools, methods and techniques to support innovation activities.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree

Social - Staff

31. During personal conversations, the contribution I make to a (more) innovative organization is considered.
info_outline

This contribution can be diverse. For example: participating in new projects, active knowledge sharing, learning new skills. But also supporting an open, creative atmosphere internally.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
32. The organization has a well-developed talent management and HR development policy focused on competencies and skills needed for innovation.
info_outline

In conjunction with a good vision on which talents may still need to be hired externally.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
33. We have ongoing access to training, workshops and courses in relevant professional and work areas.
info_outline

Competence in all areas of methods, tools and techniques in the field of innovation are recognized as important. HR policies for managers and employees focus on multiple levels of proficiency in developing new products, services and processes.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
34. Personal ambitions and motivations are recorded in writing and, where relevant, related to the goals the organization wants to achieve.
info_outline

Recordings can be formal in the personnel file or informal in periodic bilateral consultations. An open atmosphere where managers and employees work in line with their personal ambitions and talents is an important factor for innovation success.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
35. Individual employees are challenged to make a personal contribution with respect to innovation.
info_outline

Intrinsic motivation and personal growth to contribute is fueled when the manager supports it and challenges employees.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree

Execution - Resources

36. The maturity of the organization as a whole in terms of planning and releasing resources for innovation is at the right level.
info_outline

Here we ask about the extent to which the handling of administrative processes and provision of resources around innovation projects is smooth.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
37. We have good and effective processes to determine on a regular basis the resources (financial, people, facilities) needed for our innovation activities.
info_outline

Good support that is periodically adjusted in line with progress is essential to achieving innovation success.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
38. Innovations are always accompanied by a business case: the return can be financial or quality improvement, but without a positive outcome we do not start the project.
info_outline

At first, a positive outcome may be difficult to measure, but still: a positive outcome provides a measurable point for success. Such as: has the (quantitative or qualitative) objective been achieved? The question here is whether there is a focus on creating value for the organization or customer.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
39. We can procure or otherwise deploy desired third-party services related to an innovative activity as needed.
info_outline

The employees must of course comply with the procurement procedures within the government or the organisation. The question particularly relates to the extent to which this can be done satisfactorily, focusing not so much on the procedure but on the result: does it lead to the right selection of the supplier or partner with whom to develop the solution?

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
40. In the organization, for the purpose of innovation processes and management, a specifically created unit, department or team is active.
info_outline

Examples include an in-house innovation lab, program or team. What is meant here is a structural organizational interpretation of the innovation management function (i.e. not just temporary / project teams for innovation projects).

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree

Execution - Planning

41. We employ a continuous process to support the activities of teams as needed during all phases of innovation projects.
info_outline

Phasing of an innovation project usually takes place along 3 clusters: explore (leading to a promising concept), experiment (leading to a proven concept) and excel (achieving success after implementation).

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
42. Innovation projects always involve (periodic) risk analyses.
info_outline

There are various (comprehensive) tools in circulation to help determine the probability and impact of risks. These should be used. For example, the use of the PMK Project Management Assessment can be helpful here. But also a simple textual enumeration of possible risks in table form with a discussion of impact and probability can already be an effective way of such an analysis.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
43. The organization employs a life cycle approach, which takes into account that products, services, and processes must be introduced, change, and eventually disappear and be replaced over time.
info_outline

A life cycle approach means planning not only for start-up and introduction moments, but also for modification and parting with products and services. This allows for smooth anticipation (with time and money) of further future development or scaling down.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
44. The organization can cope well with the situation of continuing to function in an effective way while at the same time wanting to be agile and able to implement (radical) innovation.
info_outline

This is referred to in innovation management terminology as the necessary 'ambidexterity' or 'two-handedness'. It is needed for the friction that can arise within an organization when existing activities demand all the resources and attention and no room is left for development, while this is seen as necessary.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
45. Within our organization, not only are stand-alone innovation projects implemented, but there is the application of a coherent approach (portfolio management) in line with our mission, vision and strategy.
info_outline

Within our organization, not only are stand-alone innovation projects implemented, but there is the application of a coherent approach (portfolio management) in line with our mission, vision and strategy.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree

Execution - Projects

46. Results from interaction with end users about the product, service and/or process (to be developed) are systematically collected, analyzed and used in the implementation of innovation projects.
info_outline

For example, by deploying a Minimum Viable Product (MVP), user experiences can be quickly converted for improvement on the way to a proven concept before actual implementation.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
47. We actively form consortia, ecosystems and networks based on (among other things) open innovation and/or participation in public/private partnerships.
info_outline

This makes this attitude of the organization the antithesis of the Not Invented Here Syndrome. Of course, this is also a matter of 'where desirable': within the security domain, closed, even secret, innovation is more likely to occur. In this context, closed information disclosure would actually be necessary (and therefore normal).

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
48. Within each innovation project, we periodically conduct a progress and quality measurement based on which adjustments can be made.
info_outline

A periodic measurement - especially in long-term projects - provides insight into factors that require extra attention. In projects, the required competencies and commitment will change as the delivery progresses. This also belongs to the domain of the periodic measurement: team composition, management and governance must remain in line with the phase in which the project is located.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
49. We are able to scale up outcomes of pilots and projects and successfully implement them within the organization.
info_outline

An innovation is only successful if it has a positive impact on regular or new activities, or has been implemented completely independently.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
50. Management provides the necessary support to employees and teams during the deployment of innovative activities.
info_outline

The employees feel supported by the managers in carrying out new developments involving many uncertainties that make this support necessary.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree

Control - Monitoring

51. Managers have sufficient insight based on tools, dashboards and reports to oversee innovation activities and monitor progress.
info_outline

This could be a cycle of meetings and reports, for example. Or an elaborate portfolio management report.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
52. Management monitors trends and analyzes them using the outcomes for continuous improvement of efforts at innovation.
info_outline

Technological or social developments can move so fast worldwide that it is impossible to keep up with them structurally on all fronts. However, the organization can take appropriate measures to remain well-informed and to conduct regular research into which developments are expected to have an impact on the organization.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
53. Our organization embraces working data-driven, which is reflected in activities related to ongoing monitoring, information gathering and improving data quality.
info_outline

Data and information is seen in the organization to fuel many innovative and related, support processes.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
54. Monitoring and measuring within our organization is sufficient to determine whether the objectives around innovation management and projects are being achieved.
info_outline

Is the monitoring sufficiently in line, also in relation to the principles used in policy documents, annual plans and strategy?

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
55. Outcomes of monitoring and measurement are shared (edited or not) and regularly discussed organization-wide.
info_outline

This also includes in a broad sense knowledge sharing (expertise, lessons learned).

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree

Control - Adjustment

56. In our organization, there is a continuous focus on optimizing activities and improving work processes around innovation.
info_outline

This manifests itself in a formal sense (working agreements, action and decision lists), but also in an informal sense (for example, managers do or do not act on suggestions from innovation teams).

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
57. We make corrections based on monitoring and measuring.
info_outline

This can range from corrective actions by management to stopping projects where desirable based on predetermined failure factors. A so-called 'early exit' then belongs to the regular field of innovation.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
58. Management has identified and clearly articulated key factors for successful implementations of innovations.
info_outline

Also called 'key factors for success': when is an innovation successful? Is that simply after implementation or are specific results also expected and announced in advance?

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
59. The feedback and insights of end users are structurally included in the development of new products and/or services.
info_outline

Input from stakeholders and in particular end users is seen as an essential part of innovation processes.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree
60. Important decisions are usually made based on analyzed and easily interpretable data (in the form of management reports, dashboards, etc).
info_outline

The organization then has at its disposal effective methods for information gathering, analysis, and reporting. There is information-driven working in decision making.

Totally disagree
Totally agree
Totally disagree
Totally agree